March Week 2: Habits Move, They Don’t Break
There is a popular image of habit change that involves snapping something in two.
You break the habit. You cut it out. You leave it behind. Clean lines. Clear endings. A new chapter. In reality, habits rarely break. They move, sometimes with surprising creativity.
They shrink, expand, relocate, disguise themselves, resurface under stress and soften under care. They are living systems shaped by cues, context, reward and repetition. Expecting them to disappear overnight is a little like expecting a river to stop flowing because you have decided to walk in a different direction.
Addiction psychology has understood this for decades. Alan Marlatt’s relapse prevention model made a crucial distinction between a lapse and a relapse. A lapse is a momentary return to an old behaviour. A relapse is a sustained return to previous levels of engagement. What often determines the difference is not the lapse itself, but the meaning attached to it. When a lapse is interpreted as total failure, what Marlatt called the abstinence violation effect can take hold. A single slip becomes evidence of weakness. Shame increases. Behaviour escalates. The story becomes self-fulfilling. When the same lapse is understood as data, something else happens. Curiosity replaces condemnation. The question shifts from what is wrong with me to what happened here.
Research into self-compassion supports this distinction. Studies led by Kristin Neff and others consistently show that people who respond to setbacks with kindness rather than harsh self-criticism are more likely to persist in behaviour change over time. Compassion does not reduce standards. It stabilises effort. Habits, especially those involving technology, are particularly prone to this cycle.
You decide to reduce screen time. You succeed for three days. On the fourth, you scroll late into the night. The threat system steps in. You have ruined it. You are back where you started. The following day feels heavier, so you scroll again. But behaviourally speaking, you are not back at the beginning. Neural pathways do not reset overnight. Patterns that have been interrupted even briefly are already shifting. The nervous system has new information.
Habit research increasingly emphasises context rather than character. Wendy Wood’s work on habit suggests that up to forty percent of daily behaviour is automatic and context-driven. Change the context and the behaviour often follows. Leave the context untouched and willpower has to work far harder. This is why habits move rather than break. If you remove one cue, another may step in. If you restrict one behaviour, another may attempt to meet the same need. Leaving things to willpower alone, is an unfair fight.
The question becomes less how do I eliminate this habit and more what function is this behaviour serving? Is it relief from boredom? Regulation after stress? A substitute for connection? A pause between tasks? A way of avoiding something harder?
From an Acceptance and Commitment Therapy perspective, the work is not simply to suppress behaviour but to widen awareness. To notice the urge without immediately obeying it. To choose in line with values even when the habit loop is activated. Practically, this might mean mapping the loop rather than attacking it. What time does the behaviour occur? What precedes it? What emotion is present? What reward follows?
Then adjust one element at a time.
If late-night scrolling meets a need for decompression, replace it not with prohibition but with an alternative ritual that offers similar regulation. A short podcast rather than infinite feed. Music with the phone charging out of reach. Ten minutes of deliberate browsing rather than forty minutes of drift. If stress triggers checking behaviour, build a brief pause before unlocking the screen. Three breaths. A stretch. A glass of water. Not as punishment, but as interruption – a short circuit.
Habits respond to shaping more than shaming, though shaming does tend to make us feel briefly productive. March is a month for this kind of shaping. Movement without violence. Adjustment without theatrics. Acknowledging that lapses will occur and planning for them rather than pretending they will not. When a habit resurfaces, resist the dramatic narrative. You have not failed. Acknowledge any black and white, all-or-nothing thoughts that might arise. The river has simply found a familiar bend. Your task is to guide it gradually towards a new channel.
Habits move. So can you.
Seen through the lens of Compassion Focused Therapy, setbacks often activate predictable internal patterns. Threat thoughts may say: you have no willpower, you always do this, you might as well give up. Drive thoughts may counter with: double down, be stricter, remove everything enjoyable. Neither is entirely wrong. Both are trying to help in their own way. But without the soothing system, they become extreme. Soothing thoughts sound different: this is uncomfortable, but it is workable. A lapse is information, not identity. We can adjust and continue. Learning to recognise these three systems in real time is often more transformative than any single habit hack.
Just One More Thing
This week, map one habit loop on paper. Draw three columns: trigger, behaviour, reward. Keep it simple. When you notice the habit, jot down what preceded it and what you felt afterwards. Then add a fourth column: system voice. Was threat, drive or soothing most active?
Research on self-compassion suggests that responding to setbacks with warmth increases persistence. So when the habit reappears, practise one sentence of deliberate kindness. Not indulgence. Kindness. For example: this is a wobble, not a collapse.
Small shifts, repeated gently, reshape patterns over time.
About the Author
Dr. Richard Pomfret is a HCPC-registered Counselling Psychologist and founder of Therapy On The Hill. He works with adults experiencing a range of emotional and psychological difficulties, offering evidence-based therapy in a compassionate and collaborative way.
Contact
If you’d like to learn more about therapy or enquire about working together, you can contact Richard at: